[00:00:04]
[ TOWN OF GREENBURGH ANTENNA REVIEW BOARD 177 Hillside Avenue, Greenburgh, NY 10607 CATHERINE LEDERER-PLASKETT Chair ]
TODAY IS, UH, LET ME, TODAY IS DECEMBER 15TH, 2025, MONDAY, AND THE MEETING WAS CALLED FOR SIX.NOW I'M GONNA TAKE ATTENDANCE TO MAKE SURE WE HAVE A QUORUM PRESENT.
CATHERINE LETTER OF SKET HERE.
FRANCIS SHEEN IS HERE AS A LIAISON PRESENT.
UM, WE ARE CONVENED TO REVIEW THREE APPLICATIONS.
WE ARE IN THE TOWN OF GREENBURG QUORUM, PRESENT TOWN OF GREENBURG BUILDING, UM, LEAH JACKSON, ROOM TOWN HALL.
AND WE ARE CONVENED TO REVIEW THE SUBMISSION OF 55 JACKSON AVENUE, 1 0 5 PO STREET.
YEAH, I JUST HAVE TO MAKE SURE I HAVE MY PAPERS ON AT 6 44.
SO LET'S START WITH 55 JACKSON.
UM, JUST FOR THE RECORD, PAUL COSTA IS ON AS WELL.
SO WE'RE GOING TO LOOK FIRST AT 55 JACKSON AVENUE.
IT WAS SUBMITTED ON THE 3RD OF DECEMBER.
TODAY IS THE 15TH OF DECEMBER, BOTH IN 2025.
PLEASE, DIANE OR FRANCIS, STOP ME IF YOU WANT TO ADD MORE, UM, OR HAVE A QUESTION, BUT IN A, WE NEED THE LICENSE NUMBER FOR DENNIS AND WE NEED THE CREDENTIALS FOR ME AND I YES.
SO FOR THAT, I DON'T KNOW HOW WE CAN GET YOU A LICENSE NUMBER FOR DENNIS BECAUSE HE IS NOT A REGISTERED, HE DOESN'T HAVE A PE STAMP.
AUDIO ENGINEERS DON'T HAVE PE STAMPS.
IT SAYS ON THIS, THAT I LOOKED UP ON THE WEB BECAUSE IT DOESN GOES TO THE WEB AND IT SAYS THAT HE'S A MECHANICAL ENGINEER.
THAT DOESN'T MEAN HE HAS A PE STAMP.
I DIDN'T SAY A STAMP, I SAID A LICENSE NUMBER.
WHAT TYPE OF LICENSE SHOULD WE, WHAT NUMBER? WELL, I WOULD SUGGEST YOU LOOK AT GOOGLE ALSO, AND YOU'LL SEE THAT THEY REQUIRE A LICENSE NUMBER AND HAVE FOR WHAT? MECHANICAL ENGINEERS.
YOU HAVE D WHAT DOES GOOGLE SHOW? LET, LET, LET ME SIMPLY, LET ME SIMPLY CALL THIS MEETING TO ORDER IN A CIVIL TONE.
PLEASE DO NOT INTERRUPT ME AND I WILL NOT INTERRUPT YOU.
ACCORDING TO GOOGLE, MECHANICAL ENGINEERS HAVE LICENSE NUMBERS.
THAT'S NOT A STAMP, THAT'S A LICENSE NUMBER.
IF YOU HAVE DIFFICULTY GETTING THE LICENSE NUMBER, LET US KNOW.
AND OKAY, IF I DO HAVE DIFFICULTY GETTING THAT, HOW DO I LET YOU KNOW? BECAUSE I DON'T WANNA SUBMIT AN ENTIRE APPLICATION.
YOU CAN EMAIL US AND SAY WE ARE HAVING DIFFICULTY.
DO YOU KNOW WHERE WE MIGHT LOOK? AND I WILL GO BACK TO WHAT I FOUND AND I WILL SEND YOU THE LINK.
AND NOW IF THIS GUY DOES NOT HAVE A LICENSE NUMBER, JUST BECAUSE HE, I DON'T KNOW WHERE YOU FOUND HE'S A MECHANICAL ENGINEER, HE MIGHT HAVE THAT.
SO THEN YOU'RE GOING TO, I I DON'T THINK YOU'RE LISTENING TO HER.
IF YOU HAVE ISSUES, EMAIL HER AND YOU COULD STRAIGHTEN IT OUT.
BUT WE'RE NOT GONNA SPEND THREE HOURS GOING BACK AND FORTH REGARDING A LICENSE NUMBER, NUMBER.
AND THEN WHAT TYPE OF CREDENTIALS DO YOU WANT FOR THE OTHER PERSON? WHERE HAS SHE WORKED? THAT PERSON WORKED? WHERE HAVE THEY BEEN EDUCATED? SOMETHING THAT ACTUALLY GIVES THEM CRED, CREDENTIALS TO, AND IT SAYS ON THIS, AND YOU'VE DONE THIS BEFORE, QUALIFICATIONS ARE CRITICAL.
DO YOU WANT, WOULD A RESUME SUFFICE IF THE RESUME IS DETAILED? YES.
IF THE RESUME JUST SAID GIVES AN ADDRESS WHERE THE PERSON LIVES? NO, THE PERSON CLEARLY GOT THE JOB FOR A REASON.
AND AGAIN, THIS WAS NOT REQUIRED ON OUR GOLDEN APPLICATION.
SO I'M CONFUSED AS WHY THIS IS A NEW REQUIREMENT.
[00:05:02]
WELL, I'M GOING ON TO B NOW.A PERSON MUST BE PROVIDED FOR EACH ENTITY TO PROVIDE CON MEDICINE'S.
GENERIC NAME DOES NOT HELP JUDGE GENERIC PHONE NUMBER.
ALSO, APPLICANT WAS LI MISSING C GREENBERG IS IN THE AD, IN THE ADDRESS IS INCORRECT.
MAKE SURE YOU HAVE THE CORRECT PO.
IT MUST INCLUDE THE POLL REPLACEMENT IN THE DESCRIPTION.
THE ADDRESS OF THE DRAWINGS, THE ADDRESS ON THE DRAWINGS, CONFLICTS WITH THE, WITH THE ADDRESS IN OTHER PLACES.
THE DOCUMENT PROVIDED IS FOR 1 79 JACKSON AVENUE.
THE APPLICATION IS FOR 55 JACKSON AVENUE AND SCARSDALE IS MISS DISPLAYED.
I COMPLETE J COMPLETE K COMPLETE L COMPLETE M COMPLETE N INCOMPLETE.
EACH SITE MUST PROVIDE ITS OWN SITE SPECIFIC DATA.
DATA MUST, UM, CORRESPOND TO THE SPECIFIC SITE.
ALSO IN THIS REPORT YOU HAVE 4.5 AS THE MAXIMUM, AND THEN YOU ALSO HAVE THREE POINT 33 AS THE MAXIMUM.
CAN I SPEAK TO THIS ONE? AND YOU ALSO HAVE THE WRONG CENTER LINE FOR WHAT'S ON YOUR DRAWING.
SO IT DOESN'T MATCH THE RF REPORT.
UM, I'M CONFUSED AS WHY WE SPENT ALMOST A WHOLE YEAR GOING OVER THE GOLDEN AND IN THAT ONE.
OKAY, LET ME, LET ME, LET ME SAVE YOU ALL YOUR WORDS.
WE DIDN'T LOOK FOR SOMEONE TO BE TRYING TO FOOL US.
WHEN YOU NOW LOOK AT RF REPORTS, AND WE WENT OVER THIS WITH LAURA AND THEY ALL HAVE THE SAME HEIGHT AND THEY HAVE THE SAME RF AT 10 FEET AS THE MAXIMUM.
WE HAD ONE REPORT FROM YOU AND WE DID NOT LOOK FOR SOMEONE TO BE INTENTIONALLY MISLEADING US.
I AM ASSUMING YOU ARE NOT INTENTIONALLY MISLEADING US NOW, BUT THESE ARE BUT THESE ARE SITE SPECIFIC.
WHERE DOES IT, WHERE DOES IT SAY IN THE CODE? IT HAS TO BE SITE SPECIFIC.
IT TALKS ABOUT THE ADDRESS AND THEN THE IMPACTS ON THAT ADDRESS.
THE FACT THAT YOU DO SOMETHING ON CELLAR STREET AND YOU ARE USING THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT OF HELICOPTERS OR AIR TRAFFIC GOING OVER CELLAR STREET IN NEW JERSEY.
BUT THAT'S, THAT'S THE, THAT'S THE SAME EXAMPLE.
THE SAME TYPE OF AN EXAMPLE, BUT BASELINE OF A FACTORY IN NEW JERSEY FOR EACH ONE OF THESE SITES JUST DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE.
WELL I'M TALKING ABOUT THE R REPORT.
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE, IT SAYS, IT SAYS IN THE FIRST SENTENCE CERTIFICATION THAT THE NEAR LEVELS AT THE PROPOSED SITE, NOT GENERIC SITE, NOT IMAGINARY SITE.
THAT'S THE VERY, THAT'S THE 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, SEVENTH WORD.
SO EVEN THOUGH THE WE PRO PROVIDED THE SAME REPORT FOR THE GOLDEN APPLICATION, IF YOU WOULD LIKE, WE CAN GO BACK AND CAN I JUST SAY, CAN I, CAN YOU STOP CUTTING ME OFF? WE THOUGHT WE WERE GONNA SPEAK CIVIL.
WE EVEN SAID TO YOU, THIS IS A GENERIC REPORT.
PAUL, DO NOT, I DO, I HAVE YOUR NOTES RIGHT HERE IN SEPTEMBER YOU SAID, AND I HAVE THE NOTES I CAN PROVIDE THEM TO YOU.
I SAID, THIS IS, YOU SAID PLEASE WRITE AND I'LL READ 'EM.
IT SAYS IDENTIFY, IT SAYS, LEMME BRING IT UP HERE IN SEPTEMBER.
I, YOU, YOU RECOGNIZE AS IT WAS A GENERIC REPORT AND YOU SAID THAT WAS OKAY, THAT WE JUST HAVE TO NOTIFY YOU.
NO, I HAVE NEVER SINCE 1996 EVER.
AND I'VE CHAIRED THIS BOARD SINCE 1996.
I HAVE NEVER ACCEPTED A GENERIC REPORT EVER.
THEN IT SAYS, EXPLAIN THAT THIS IS BASED ON A MODELING A NOT AN ACTUAL MEASUREMENT.
AND THEN WE REC AND THEN OUR GOLDEN REPORT SAYS THIS IS A GENERIC REPORT.
YOU PLEASE TAKE THE, YOU COULD DO A MODELING AT THE SITE.
[00:10:01]
THE SITE.'CAUSE IF YOU DON'T HAVE SOMETHING ELSE, IF YOU DON'T HAVE SOMETHING UP YET, THEN YOU DO MODELING.
BUT THAT DOESN'T MEAN YOU DO MODELING OF SOMETHING FOR ONE, ONE APPLICATION.
WHAT CATHERINE IS SAYING IS WHEN YOU GIVE US ONE REPORT, WE DON'T KNOW THAT THAT'S GOING TO BE WHAT YOU INTEND TO USE AS A STANDARD ON EVERY OTHER SITE.
EVEN THOUGH THE CODE SAYS ON THE SUBJECT SITE, THE PROPOSED SITE.
AND WHEN YOU SAY WHERE IS THE CODE, DOES IT SAY YOU HAVE TO DO AT THE PROPOSED SITE AND IT SAYS PROPOSED SITE? YEAH.
YOU KNOW, THIS IS NOT YOUR FIRST RODEO HERE, PAUL.
AND WHY EVERY TIME THERE'S AN APPLICATION THAT COMES IN, YOU TRY TO FIND CON UH, CONFRONTATION AND DON'T GIVE US WHAT WE NEED.
DON'T EVEN GET THE ADDRESS RIGHT IN THE REPORT.
MAYBE YOU GET PAID BY THE HOUR, PAUL, WE DON'T.
BUT THIS IS, THIS IS REALLY ABSOLUTELY BEYOND.
YOU DON'T EVEN HAVE THE ADDRESS.
UH, WE SURE, I MEAN WE'LL JUST KEEP SUBMITTING THESE THEN BECAUSE THERE'S NO GOLDEN RECORD HERE, BUT, OKAY, SO UNDER NEAR, THEY ARE, THESE ARE GENERIC.
EACH SITE MUST PROVIDE SITE SPECIFIC DATA.
DATA MUST CORRESPOND TO THE SPECIFIC SITE.
INCLUDED IN THIS IS THE, UM, APPLICATION SAYS 4.5 IS THE MAXIMUM.
AND IT ALSO SAYS 3.33 IS THE MAXIMUM CENTER LINE DOES NOT MATCH THE REPORT.
CHANGE THE, OKAY, SO THAT IS NEAR AND THAT IS INCOMPLETE.
OH, CHANGE THE LANGUAGE FROM AFFIRMATIVE OBLIGATION TO T-MOBILE WILL TAKE THE STEPS OR MAYBE IT SHOULD ADD CROWN AND T-MOBILE.
UH, I I'M TRYING TO UNDERSTAND WHY THAT CHANGE NEEDS TO BE HAPPENING.
IT'S OUR OWN
WE ARE CHANGING THE LANGUAGE SO THAT IT SAYS YOU WILL CORRECT IT IF IT IS THERE.
WE, THIS IS ALSO NOT OUR FIRST RODEO AND WE'VE BEEN THROUGH THIS WORK WITH MANY, MANY PROVIDERS AND NO ONE HAS HAD A PROBLEM SAYING IF THERE IS A PROBLEM, THEY WILL CORRECT IT.
AFFIRMATIVE OBLIGATION DOES NOT SAY THAT.
CHANGE THE LANGUAGE FROM AFFIRMATIVE OBLIGATION TO CROWN AND T-MOBILE WILL TAKE THE STEPS NECESSARY TO CORRECT IT.
THESE NEED TO BE SITE SPECIFIC.
THERE'S A CONTRADICTION CONFLICT BETWEEN THE DATE OF THE REPORT OF ISSU ISSUANCE, I'M SORRY, OF THE REPORT AND OF, OF THE ISSUANCE SIGNATURE.
IN ADDITION, THESE ARE ARE DONE AT A FACTORY IN NEW JERSEY.
THEY TAKE AM, UM, AMBIENT NOISE, ET CETERA FROM THE STREET WHERE THE FACTORY IS LOCATED.
THESE NEED TO BE SITE SPECIFIC INCOMPLETE, EVEN THOUGH THE NOISE IS BELOW WHAT IS REQUIRED.
A DP LEVEL IS THE SAME IN NEW JERSEY AS IT'S SAME IN GREENBURG.
SO EVEN IF THE AMBIENT NOISE IS ABOVE OR BELOW US, WE MEET THE CODE.
YEAH, READ THE, READ THE REPORT.
IT GIVES THE AMBIENT LEVEL AS DESCRIBED AT THAT SITE ON A STREET THAT YOU DIDN'T CAPITALIZE, WHICH IS THE ADDRESS OF THE FACTORY.
SO THAT IS NOT THE SAME, JUST LIKE KENNEDY AIRPORT IS NOT THE SAME AS POST STREET.
IT EVEN TALKS ABOUT THE AIR TRAFFIC.
UM, GOING ON QA PROPOSED SCHEDULE FOR INSTALLATION AND COMPLETION OF THE MOD, UM, OF THE MODIFICATIONS PROPOSED, THE DATE GIVEN IN THAT IS 6 9 20 25.
TODAY'S ALREADY THE, THE, UH, 15TH OF, UM, DECEMBER.
THE DATE NEEDS TO BE FIXED AT A MINIMUM, BUT YOU'LL ALSO HAVE TO JUNE 9TH DATE THAT APPEAR, RIGHT? YEAH.
IF, IF, UM, YOU'RE ALSO GONNA HAVE TO INCLUDE IN THAT PARAGRAPH THAT YOU HAVE THE TIME IT TAKES TO INSTALL THE POLE.
UM, SHROUD IS NOT FOUR FEET, UM, IS NOT ON SHEET.
FOUR OF EIGHT IS 14 FEET, NINE INCHES, NOT 14 FEET, EIGHT INCHES.
[00:15:01]
POLES ON FOUR OF EIGHT.ALL OWNERSHIP TO DEFINE EQUIPMENT.
WHAT DOES DEFINE EQUIPMENT MEAN? THAT YOU USE THE TERM YOU USE THE TERM EQUIPMENT.
WHAT DOES EQUIPMENT CONSTITUTE? OKAY, I'LL LIST.
EVERY SINGLE EQUIPMENT IS COMPLETE.
WE IS INCOMPLETE BECAUSE THE ADDRESS NEEDS TO BE CORRECT.
ADDRESS NEEDS TO BE CONSISTENT.
SO YOU HAVE IN THE FIRST INSURANCE OF PROPERTY REPLACEMENT, IT'S INCOMPLETE AS IS THE IT INCOMPLETE.
FOUR THREE BECAUSE OF THE ADDRESS WORKERS' COMP, BECAUSE THERE'S NO ADDRESS REQUIRED.
I I VOTE THAT WE, UM, I I MAKE A MOTION THAT WE DEEM THIS APPLICATION INCOMPLETE.
I, YES, THIS IS ALL THE SAME STUFF.
THERE'S NOT GONNA BE ANY CHANGE ON IT, SO WE NEED TO GO THROUGH IT BECAUSE WE FOLLOWED THE LAW.
NEED THE LICENSE NUMBER FOR DENNIS? TWO.
WE NEED, UH, KNEE ADDED TO THE APPLICATION.
KNEE IS OMITTED FROM THIS APPLICATION FOR SOME REASON.
AND THEN THREE, WE NEED THE CREDENTIALS FOR NEED AND IB, WE NEED THE PERSON'S NAME.
PERSON, UM, PERSON MADE TO BE NEEDS.
I'M SORRY, PERSON NEEDS TO BE ADDED FOR EACH ONE.
CAN I ASK A QUESTION ON THIS? WHEN WE PUT THE NAMES IN THIS, ARE YOU THEN ALSO GONNA ASK FOR QUALIFICATIONS? WHAT DOES THE QUESTION SAY? I KNOW THE QUESTION.
WHAT THE QUESTION B READS, NAMES, ADDRESSES, AND LANDLINES.
BUT ABOVE IT ALSO SAYS NAMES, ADDRESSES, QUALIFICATIONS, PERSON, PARENT REPORT, AND HIS OR SIGNATURE.
SO I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE IF YOU PUT A NAME IN THERE, PAUL.
YEAH, IF YOU ACTUALLY READ THE QUESTION.
ONE IS THE PEOPLE SIGNING OFF ON THE REPORT AND THE OTHER IS THE PEOPLE WHO HEAD UP THE ORGANIZATIONS, THE, OR WHO ARE THE OWNER OPERATOR AND APPLICANT.
IT'S VERY CLEAR WHAT WE'RE ASKING FOR.
C IS COMPLETE, D IS COMPLETE, B IS COMPLETE, F IS NOT IT'S INCOMPLETE.
UM, UH, I'M, I'M NOT SURE WHAT THAT ONE PLEASE.
I AM LOOKING AT WHAT MY NOTES HEARSAY.
OH, THE A THE INFORMATION ON 12 IS DIFFERENT THAN THE INFORMATION WE'VE ACCEPTED FROM THE OTHERS FOR THE IDENTIFICATION OF THE SITE.
AND CAN I, UH, THAT IS BECAUSE IT'S A DIFFERENT AGREEMENT.
AND IF WE NOT THAT IN THE LETTER.
AND WE NOTED THAT IN THE LETTER THAT THOSE TWO, THERE'S TWO THAT ARE, HAVE DIFFERENT AGREEMENTS IN THERE.
SO YOU HAVEN'T HIGHLIGHTED AND YOU HAVEN'T PROVIDED THE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION THAT YOU HAVE ON THE OTHERS THAT MADE US KNOW THAT THESE WERE ACTUALLY CORRESPONDING.
SO MAKE THE MATCH, EVEN IF YOU HAVE TO FILL IT IN AND NOT COPY IT DIRECTLY FROM SOMETHING ELSE.
I DON'T, I'M STILL NOT FOLLOWING.
WE, THERE'S A, IT CONTAINS THE SAME THINGS.
WELL, IF YOU LOOK AT THEM, IF YOU LOOK AT THEM, ACTUALLY THEY'RE NOT THE SAME THING.
I'LL ASK LAURA TO DO IT OR MAKE TO DO IT.
TO COMPARE WHAT YOU PROVIDE IN ONE TO COMPARE IT WITH WHAT YOU PROVIDE IN THE OTHER.
AND THIS DOES NOT PROVIDE THE INFORMATION AND IT'S NOT CONSISTENT.
YOU HIGHLIGHTED AND ADD THE OTHER INFORMATION THAT YOU ADDED IN.
THE OTHER SHOULD BE AVAILABLE TO YOU.
G TWO PROVIDERS ARE ON THIS SITE.
THEY NEED TO BE INCLUDED IN THE DESCRIPTION OF THE WORK.
AND NOW, UM, I HAVE A QUESTION THERE.
THERE'S NOTHING HAPPENING TO VERIZON.
SO WHAT ARE WE SUPPOSED TO DESCRIBE THE WORK, WORK BEING DONE TO VERIZON? ARE YOU REPLACING A SHROUD WHERE VERIZON
[00:20:01]
IS? YES.SO I HAVE TO SAY, I'M JUST TRYING TO UNDERSTAND THE LANGUAGE YOU'RE ASKING FOR IN THAT QUESTION BECAUSE I CAN'T, NOTHING'S HAPPENING TO VERIZON.
SO YOU WANT ME TO SAY WE'RE GONNA TAKE THAT OUT AND PUT IT BACK IN? YES.
IT SAYS ALL WORK NECESSARY TO COMPLETE THIS.
I MEAN, DO I NEED TO DESCRIBE THE METER AND THE WIRES THAT WE'RE MOVING AND REPLACING AS WELL? IT WOULD BE HELPFUL.
H IS, I DON'T KNOW IF H IS COMPLETE.
WHAT WAS H THIS ADDRESS IS INCORRECT ON THE PERMIT.
OH, THIS IS NOT YOUR RESPONSIBILITY.
THIS HAPPENED WITH THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT.
THE ADDRESS ON THE COC IS INCOMPLETE IS INCORRECT.
IT SAYS SCARSDALE SHOULD BE HARSDALE.
BUT THAT'S NOT YOUR, THAT BUILDING DEPARTMENT ACCEPTED IT WHEN IT WAS DONE FIRST.
SO WOULD WE MARK THAT COMPLETE? UM, I IS INCOMPLETE.
ALL WIRELESS PROVIDERS ARE TO BE INCLUDED.
ALL APPLICATIONS, INCLUDING ALL UPGRADES HAVE, HAVE HAD TO COME BEFORE THE ANTENNA BOARD SINCE 1996.
EXHIBIT 13 ADD A TAB BECAUSE AT FIRST THANK THANKS TO OTHERS.
IT'S BECAUSE EVERYTHING ELSE HAS A TAB.
DIANE, YOU COULD GIVE HER CREDIT.
THIS IS NOT, THE TAB IS NOT COMPLIANT.
THE INFORMATION THERE IS NOT COMPLIANT WITH THE CODE PROVISIONS BECAUSE IT DID NOT INCLUDE THE DATA REQUIRED.
I GUESS, CAN I ASK SOME MORE QUESTIONS ON THIS? WHAT, WHAT ARE YOU LOOKING FOR THEN? MUST INCLUDE VERIZON.
WHICH LETTER ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT? HE'S TALKING ABOUT I, WELL IT SAYS IF THE WIRELESS FACILITY IS BEING MODIFIED, WE'LL PROVIDE SERVICE TO ANOTHER WIRELESS SERVICE PROVIDER.
SO WHY VERIZON IS IN THERE AND VERIZON IS GETTING PROVI SERVICE PROVIDED.
AND YOU'RE SAYING THIS IS T-MOBILE SITES, SO THEY HAVE TO BE INCLUDED.
BUT WHAT DOES THAT MEAN? WE'VE NOTED VERIZON IS ALSO LOCATED TO THE SITE.
WHAT, LIKE WHAT, WHAT DO YOU NEED AS ASSIGNED? LET'S READ IT TOGETHER THEN MAYBE THAT'LL MAKE IT CLEAR.
I DON'T, YOU'RE, I I'M TRYING TO UNDERSTAND YOUR REQUIREMENT HERE BECAUSE I'M TRYING TO READ IT SO THAT WE CAN MAKE IT VERY CLEAR AS WE GO ALONG.
IF THE WIRELESS FACILITY BEING MODIFIED WILL PROVIDE SERVICE TO ANOTHER WIRELESS SERVICE PROVIDER, A SIGNED AGREEMENT OR OTHER DOCUMENTATION CLEARLY SHOWING THE WIRELESS SERVICE PROVIDER ON BEHALF OF WHICH THE WIRELESS FACILITY WILL BE PROVIDING SERVICE.
SO BOTH T-MOBILE AND VERIZON ARE IN THERE.
AND CROWN IS SHOULD BE PROVIDING THAT.
IF THE APPLICANT APPEARS, UH, I'M SORRY.
IF THE APPLICANT AGREES TO PROVIDE SERVICE TO ADDITIONAL WIRELESS SERVICE PROVIDERS DURING THE COURSE OF OPERATION OF THE WIRELESS FACILITY, THE APPLICANT SHALL NO SHALL PROVIDE NOTICE TO THE TOWN ALONG WITH A SIGNED AGREEMENT OR OTHER DOCUMENTATION CLEARLY SHOWING THE WIRELESS SERVICE PROVIDERS ON BEHALF OF WHICH THE SMALL WIRELESS SERVICE FACILITY WILL BE PROVIDING SERVICE.
SO THAT WAS NOT INCLUDED AND WE NEED IT.
DO YOU NEED AN AGREEMENT? DO YOU NEED A LETTER? I MEAN ANY, BUT IT SAYS VERY CLEARLY, I BELIEVE IS AN, UH, A SIGNED AGREEMENT OR OTHER DOCUMENTATION CLEARLY SHOWING THE WIRELESS SERVICE PROVIDER ON BEHALF OF WHICH THE VI WIRELESS FACILITY WILL BE PROVIDING SERVICE.
IF THE APPLICANT AGREES TO PROVIDE SERVICE TO ADDITIONAL WIRELESS WIRELESS SERVICE PROVIDERS DURING THE COURSE OF OPERATION OF THE WIRELESS FACILITY, THE APPLICANT SHALL PROVIDE TO THE TOWN ALONG WITH A SIGNED AGREEMENT OR OTHER DOCUMENTATION CLEARLY SHOWING THE WIRELESS SERVICE PROVIDERS ON BEHALF OF WHICH THE SMALL WIRELESS SERVICE FACILITY WILL BE PROVIDING SERVICE.
WE WILL SHOW A SIGNED DOCUMENT, WHICH WE WILL DO AND THEN JAY GET APPROVED.
CAN I, CAN I INTERRUPT ON THAT ONE PLEASE? SURE.
UM, SO RIGHT NOW WE'RE PUTTING AN APPLICATION TO GET THIS, UH, ANTENNA SITE UP AND RUNNING.
AND WE HAVE A CUSTOMER OR TWO CUSTOMERS, I BELIEVE, RIGHT? WE HAVE VERIZON IN THERE.
IS THAT RIGHT? LAUREN AND PAUL? YES.
UM, SO WE WOULD, AT THIS POINT, THOSE ARE THE ONLY ONES THAT WE'RE CONSIDERING HAVING, UH, CARRYING TRAFFIC ON THIS ANTENNA.
SO THOSE WOULD BE THE TWO THAT WE WOULD INCLUDE, CORRECT? UH, YOU, YOU'RE, YOU'RE ALSO IN, IN
[00:25:01]
THAT QUESTION.IT ALSO SAYS IF WE ARE, ARE PLANNING ON PROVIDING IT TO OTHER, UH, CARRIERS, WE WOULD'VE TO, IT DOESN'T PROVIDE YOU THAT INFORMATION THAT WOULD HAPPEN AT THE TIME THAT WE, UM, FIND WHERE WE CAN POSSIBLY GET ANOTHER CARRIER.
THAT'S WHEN WE WOULD NOTIFY YOU.
RIGHT? WE DON'T HAVE TO NOTIFY YOU ANY AND ALL CARRIERS THAT WE COULD POSSIBLY PUT ON THIS THING AT THIS TIME, RIGHT? THE ANSWER YES.
THE ANSWER IS YES TO THE QUESTION.
IF YOU HAVE A FUTURE PROPOSAL COMING IN, YOU DON'T PUT IT IN THIS ONE.
MAKE SURE WE'RE CLEAR ON THAT RIGHT NOW.
NOW ANY WHAT? ANYBODY, ANY PROVIDER THAT YOU ARE NOW PLANNING TO PUT IN, THAT'S WHO WE WANT THE DOCUMENTS FOR.
IF YOU KNOW YOU'RE GOING TO BE ADDING SOMEONE, YES, YOU HAVE TO PROVIDE THAT.
BUT IF YOU DON'T KNOW YOU ARE, YOU CAN'T.
THERE'LL BE A TIME TO NOW CERTIFIC J IS COMPLETE, K IS COMPLETE.
EACH SITE MUST PROVIDE SITE SPECIFIC DATA.
DATA MUST CO CORRESPOND TO THE SPECIFIC SITE.
CENTER LINE DOES NOT MATCH THE RESPONSE.
THE RF RESPONSE, THE CHART DOES NOT REFLECT THE SPECIFIC SITE AND IT SHOULD, SO THAT IS INCOMPLETE.
OH, CERTIFICATION THAT THE PROPOSED ANTENNA WILL NOT CAUSE INTERFERENCE.
CHANGE THE LANGUAGE FROM AFFIRMATIVE OBLIGATION TO CROWN.
AND I GUESS IT SHOULD ALSO BE SAYING MO, I I SHOULD GO BACK.
T-MOBILE WELL AND VERIZON OR WHOEVER IS RES, YOU KNOW, AND VERIZON, WELL WHAT SHOULD IT BE? BECAUSE THIS ONE SAYS T-MOBILE.
DO YOU WANT TO SAY CROWN? VERIZON? I'M SORRY.
UH, WHICH, WHAT DO YOU WANT IT TO SAY? 'CAUSE YOU HAD SAID IT SHOULD SAY CROWN AND THEN YOU CAME BACK AND SAID T-MOBILE VERIZON.
THIS ONE IS, SAY THIS ONE HAS VERIZON AND T-MOBILE IN IT.
IF IT ONLY HAS T-MOBILE IN IT, THEN IT WOULD BE SILLY TO HAVE VERIZON ADDED.
BUT THIS ONE HAS ALL, YOU KNOW HAS THREE AND CROWN IS THE APPLICANT.
SO IT SHOULD READ CROWN T-MOBILE AND VERIZON WILL TAKE THE NECESSARY STEP STEPS TO CORRECT IT.
P INCOMPLETE, THESE MUST BE SITE SPECIFIC.
THEY ARE BEING DONE AT A FACTORY IN NEW JERSEY.
THEY ARE TAKING AMBIENT NOISE, ET CETERA FROM THE STREET WHERE THE FACTORY IS LOCATED.
THERE IS CONTRADICTORY CONFLICT BETWEEN THE DATE OF THE REPORT AND THE SIGNATURE PAGE, THE DATE.
WE'RE GONNA GET YOUR SITE SPECIFIC REPORT, BUT THE FRONT PAGE SAYS THAT IT WAS REVISED ON 1123.
SO, BUT HERE NOR THERE, THE SIGNATURE PAGE PREDATES THE DATE OF THE REPORT, BUT THEN THEY NOTE THAT IT WAS REVISED ON 1125 IN THE FRONT COVER PAGE.
THE SIGNATURE IS SUPPOSED TO BE PART OF A TESTING TO THE REPORT.
SO IF THE REPORT HAS BEEN REVISED AND THERE'S NO NEW SIGNATURE, IT DOESN'T MEAN THAT THEY ARE ACTUALLY ATTESTING TO IT.
Q THE DATE OF THE, OF THIS IS DECEMBER 15TH.
YEAH, R IS COMPLETE S MUST INCLUDE THE, THE GUIDE WIRES AND ANCHOR ANCHORS DRAWN OUT MUST INCLUDE VERIZON MUST DEFINE EQUIPMENT.
IDENTIFY ON BOTH POLES ON PAGE ON FOUR OF EIGHT.
P, COMPLETE U COMPLETE D COMPLETE THIS, THE INSURANCE ON THIS WAS COMPLETE.
I MOVE THAT WE DE THIS I MAKE A MOTION TO DEEM THE APPLICATION FOR 1 0 5 CODE STREET.
OKAY, I'M GONNA HAVE TO COME BACK AND ADD THEIR NAMES SINCE PRESENT FOR THIS.
MOVING ON TO 6 4 4 FOR HILL ROAD ONE A.
WE NEED THE LICENSE NUMBER FOR DENNIS.
WE NEED THE QUALIFICATIONS FOR ME.
TWO OR B, WE NEED A PERSON PROVIDED FOR EACH.
[00:30:01]
SO THOSE TWO ARE INCOMPLETE.ALL WIRELESS PROVIDERS TO BE INCLUDED.
ALL APPLICATIONS, INCLUDING UPGRADES HAVE BEEN COMING BEFORE THE ANTENNA BOARD SINCE 1996.
NOT, NOT COMPLIANT WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THE CODE.
IT DID NOT INCLUDE THE DATA REQUIRED.
J IS COMPLETE, K IS COMPLETE, L IS COMPLETE, M IS COMPLETE NEAR.
EACH SITE MUST PROVIDE SITE SPECIFIC DATA.
DATA MUST CORRESPOND TO THE SPECIFIC SITE.
CENTER LINE DOES NOT MATCH RE RE REPORT.
THE CHART DOES NOT REFLECT THE SPECIFIC SITES.
AND IT MUST READ SITE SPECIFIC IN THE RESPONSE.
CERTIFICATION OF THE PROPOSED ANTENNAS WILL NOT CAUSE INTERFERENCE.
THIS ONE SHOULD ALSO READ THE CROWN, CHANGE THE LANGUAGE FROM AFFIRMATIVE OBLIGATION TO CROWN.
VERIZON AND T-MOBILE WILL TAKE THE NECESSARY STEPS TO CORRECT IT.
E INCOMPLETE, THIS MUST BE SITE SPECIFIC.
THEY'RE, THEY'RE BEING DONE AT A FACTORY IN NEW JERSEY.
THEY'RE TAKING AMBIENT NOISE, ET CETERA FROM THE STREET WHERE THE FACTORY IS LOCATED.
THERE'S A CONTRADICTION CONFLICT BETWEEN THE DATE ON THIS REPORT AND THE SIGNATURE PAGE.
MUST IDENTIFY ALL OWNERSHIP ON BOTH POLLS ON PAGE FOUR OF EIGHT.
T IS COMPLETE, U IS COMPLETE AND THE INSURANCE IS COMPLETE.
I MOVE THAT WE DEEM THIS, UH, I MAKE A MOTION TO DEEM THIS APPLICATION INCOMPLETE.
SO JUST HAVE TO ADD TO THE PAGES.
HOW DO YOU SPELL KENNY'S LAST NAME? M UH, UPPERCASE.
KENNY, YOU ARE WATCHING ME TO MAKE SURE I DID THAT RIGHT.
YOU DO REALIZE MY LAST NAME IS SHEAN, RIGHT? I THINK I CAN HANDLE IT.
WILL YOU LOOK THROUGH THIS? I HAVE TO STILL INITIAL EVERYTHING.
WONDER IF YOU COULD DRAW A LINE TO BRING IT SO THAT ALL OF THIS IS THERE.
[00:35:07]
THE PICK A LINE.SO THEY'RE TOLD, PUT THAT ONE FIRST.
YOU, HEY LAURA, IT WAS JUST THESE THREE APPS, RIGHT? CORRECT.
SO WE HAVE A LITTLE WORK TO DO TO, TO STRAIGHTEN THESE OUT AND GET THEM WHAT THEY NEED.
SO, UM, CATHERINE, IF I COULD ASK A QUESTION, QUESTION ON 55 JACKSON AVENUE.
UM, ON H LET ME GET TO THE RIGHT.
IT'S JUST WHEN YOU'RE DONE, THAT'S THE ONE THAT'S ON.
YOU WANT ME TO DRAW LINE THIS JUST ON H? YES.
SO THE WRONG ADDRESS THAT WAS LISTED ON THE BUILDING PERMIT THAT WE HAD INITIALLY GOTTEN BACK IN 2019 IN EXHIBIT SEVEN.
UM, SO I THINK THAT WAS THE WRONG ADDRESS.
THE WRONG ADDRESS OR, UH, WE HAVE SINCE UPDATED TO THE CORRECT ADDRESS, WHICH IS 55 JACKSON AVENUE.
THE ADDRESS ON THE PERMIT 1 7 9 JACKSON AVENUE WAS WHAT IT SEEMS LIKE WAS THE CLOSEST ADDRESS AT THE TIME.
UM, IS THAT, HOW WOULD STATING THAT IN THE RESPONSE HERE BE SUFFICIENT OR HOW WOULD THERE WERE, THERE WERE MORE PLACES THAN JUST THAT.
WE ACTUALLY FOUND IT IN SEVERAL PLACES THAT THE ADDRESSES WERE INCONSISTENT.
WHEN WE GOT TO THIS PART, WHICH WAS THE C THE CERTIFICATE, WE, THERE WAS ANOTHER PLACE WHERE THIS CAME UP WHERE WE SAID THAT, UM, WE RECOGNIZED THAT IT WAS THE TOWN'S DOING THE DOCUMENT PROVIDED FOR, UM, THIS DOCUMENT.
WE RECOGNIZE THAT THE TOWN PROVIDED YOU WITH BACK, BACK IN WHAT WAS THE DATE? IT WAS THE STREET OPENING COMMITMENT.
BACK IN 20 19TH OF MAY, I THINK.
SO THAT THERE'S NOT MUCH YOU CAN DO.
YOU CAN'T CHANGE THAT, BUT OKAY.
SO IT'S NOT ON YOU IF YOU LOOK AT THE DRAWINGS.
IT'S GOT SCARSDALE HERE WITH AND IT'S MINUS AND S, WHICH WOULD BE THE LEAST OF IT.
UM, SO THEN IT SAYS IN THE, I'M TRYING TO REMEMBER ALL THE PLACES.
YEAH, ON THE, I THINK IT'S ON THE RIGHT HAND SIDE.
GREENBERG GREEN, SORRY, DOESN'T SAY GREENBERG.
IT ALSO SAYS GREENBERG IN ONE PLACE.
YEAH, IN, IN C IT SAYS, YOUR ANSWER SAYS GREENBERG AND IT GIVES THE ZIP CODE 1 0 7 0 6.
BUT WHEN WE WENT AND TRIED TO FIND THAT, IT ACTUALLY IS THE ZIP CODE IS 1 0 5 8 3 AND IT'S SCARSDALE IF WE'RE CORRECT ABOUT THE SITE THAT WE THOUGHT IT MIGHT BE.
SO YOU NEED TO, YOU MAKE UNIFORM THE ADDRESS AND MAKE SURE YOU GOT THE RIGHT AND, AND THE ONLY PLACE REALLY THAT GREENBERG IS USED IS FOR THE TOWN HALL AREA UHHUH.
AND THAT'S THE ONLY PLACE THAT GETS DELIVERED THAT WAY BECAUSE WE HAVE SO VERY MANY POS IN THIS, IN THIS TOWN.
UM, AND 1 0 7 0 6 IS HASTINGS, BUT FROM WHAT ONE, WHAT DIANE FOUND THAT ONE FIVE OF 55 IS SCARSDALE.
I, I, SO I DON'T WANT TO SAY WHAT IT IS.
OFFICE WHAT? SCARSDALE POST OFFICE? YEAH.
SCARSDALE PO NOT IN SCARSDALE, IT'S IN TOWN OF GREENBURG.
BUT I DON'T WANNA SAY WHAT THIS IS BECAUSE I DON'T KNOW WHAT IT IS, BUT THAT SHOWS THE INCONSISTENCY OF IT.
SO THAT WAS H DID YOU HAVE ANOTHER QUESTION? NO, NO.
SO H WE DON'T NEED TO CHANGE NECESSARILY ANYTHING BECAUSE THAT WAS JUST THE TOWN OR YEAH, THE, THE TOWN GAVE THE ADDRESS.
YOU'RE JUST SAYING THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE WEEK TO, TO, UM, ADDRESS, MAKE SURE THE ADDRESS IS CONSISTENT AND CORRECT? CORRECT.
AND UM, IN THIS, SORRY, BACK EIGHTH IN YOUR, FOR EXAMPLE, IN C IT SAYS 55 JACKSON AVENUE, GREENBURG, NEW YORK, 1 0 7 0 6.
THE WORD, THE WORD GREENBERG, UH, CAN ONLY BE USED FOR GREENBERG TOWN HALL ACCORDING TO THE POST OFFICE.
UH, IF YOU WANTED TO PUT PO SCARSDALE,
[00:40:01]
NEW YORK, UM, IF THIS IS TRULY IN SCARSDALE, UH, SCARSDALE POST OFFICE, UH, THAT WOULD BE GOOD.AND JUST AS AN ASIDE, THERE'S ANOTHER TYPO IN J WHERE YOU SAY PAGE FOUR OF SIX.
IT'S ACTUALLY PAGE FOUR OF SEVEN, BUT THAT WAS LIKE THE LEAST OF ANYTHING.
SO THIS ONE IS THE LAST ONE TO LOOK AT? YES.
AND THEN ONE MORE QUESTION ON THE SAME APPLICATION UNDER G ONE SEC.
I JUST HAVE TO GET IT BACK FROM DIANE.
UM, SO WHEN WE STATE THAT THERE'S GONNA BE A, UH, THAT THERE'S A PULL REPLACEMENT REQUIRED, UM, WE, DOES IT MATTER TO YOU WHE WHETHER WE KNOW THAT THE POLL, THE, THE, THE POLE REPLACEMENT WILL BE PERFORMED BY THE POLE OWNER? OR DOES IT? NO, WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR IS THE COM.
WE WANT YOU TO INCLUDE THAT IN THE ANSWER, BUT WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR IS THE COMPLETE DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT.
AND THAT IN SOME OF THEM THEY'RE POLE REPLACEMENTS AND SOME THERE AREN'T.
SO, AND THEY'VE ALL BEEN BASICALLY DESCRIBED THE SAME WAY.
BECAUSE, WE'LL, WE'LL NOTE THAT IT'S NOT CROWN CASTLE PERFORMING THE POLE REPLACEMENT.
IT'S THE, UM, POLE OWNER THAT WILL BE DOING THAT.
SO THE, THE GE STATE, THE DESCRIPTION OF ALL WORK WAS NECESSARY TO COMPLETE, INCLUDING CONSTRUCT AND INSTALL THE PROPOSED MODIFICATION, INCLUDING ANY NECESSARY AS A, UH, EXCAVATION.
IT DOESN'T, IT DOESN'T SPECIFY BY THE APPLICANT.
IT'S WHATEVER IS NECESSARY TO WORK COMPLETE.
SO YOU COULD, YOU COULD SAY SOMEBODY ELSE IS DOING THAT WORK, THAT'S FINE.
BUT IT HAS TO BE, THERE HAS TO BE PART, IT'S PART OF THE WORK THAT YOU NEED TO DO THIS PROJECT THAT NEEDS TO BE, NEEDS TO APPEAR.
SO I THINK, DOES THAT ANSWER YOUR QUESTION? YEAH.
UM, THE OTHER THING IS, UH, THE, NOT TO BE VERY TOO TECHNICAL, BUT THE TIMING OF THE POLL REPLACEMENT HAS ALREADY OCCURRED.
SO THE POLL REPLACEMENT HAS ALREADY OCCURRED WHERE THE POLL, THE NEW POLE HAS BEEN ALREADY PLACED THERE BY THE UTILITY.
SO JUST WRITE, JUST WRITE WAS INSTALLED ON X.
BECAUSE THERE'S NO CONTROL OVER THAT.
I JUST, IT SO IT'S NOT GOING TO BE DONE IN THE FUTURE? IT'S ALREADY DONE.
JUST, JUST INCLUDE THAT IN THE DESCRIPTION THAT IT HAS ALREADY BEEN COMPLETED.
BY WHOEVER OWNS THE, PRESUMABLY THERE WAS A STREET OPENING PERMIT FOR THAT, THAT WAS CONNET OR VERIZON WHO DID IT? SOMEBODY YEAH, IT WAS, IT WAS CORRECT.
YOU KNOW HOW LONG AGO THAT WAS? UM, THIS IS GREENBERG.
IT WAS DEFINITELY WITHIN THE LAST FEW MONTHS.
YOU KNOW, IF IT WAS A YEAR OR TWO, YOU COULD SAY IT WASN'T RELATED TO THIS PROJECT, BUT NO, IT WAS DEFINITELY FOR, WE PAID FOR IT.
I THINK THAT'S ALL THE QUESTIONS I HAD.
SO THAT YOU ONLY HAVE THAT ONE BACK.
I'M JUST LOOKING THROUGH TO MAKE SURE I INITIALED MY WAY THROUGH EVERYTHING.
SO YOU WILL GET A COPY OF THIS TOMORROW MORNING FROM THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT.
SO I'M, I MAKE A MOTION THAT WE ADJOURN.